Welcome to Watermark Restaurant
Watermark Restaurant, located at 188 S Erie St in Mayville, NY, offers an unforgettable dining experience with stunning lake views. Known for its exceptional seafood, including fresh fish and delectable options like the Gorgonzola Filet and grilled lobster, each dish is praised for its quality and flavor. Guests highlight the outstanding service, making it perfect for date nights or family gatherings. With a relaxed atmosphere, Watermark combines great food with a picturesque setting, creating a memorable meal each time. Whether you’re indulging in mussels or a decadent chocolate martini, you'll find every bite leaves a lasting impression.
-
188 S Erie St, Mayville, NY 14757, United States Hotline: +1 716-753-2900
Welcome to Watermark Restaurant, a culinary gem nestled along the picturesque shores of Mayville, NY. Located at 188 S Erie St, this establishment is not just a dining destination but an experience that tantalizes the senses. With exclamatory reviews from guests raving about the amazing food, beautiful views, and great service, it’s clear that Watermark has carved a niche in the hearts of both locals and visitors alike.
As you step inside, you're greeted by vistas of the lake that complement the exceptional menu. Whether you prefer leisurely dining outdoors or intimate seating indoors, Watermark offers the perfect backdrop for any occasion, from a romantic date night to a family gathering. Patrons have praised the prime cuts and fresh seafood offerings, such as the Gorgonzola filet and the savory grilled lobster, which are often recommended for their exquisite flavors and generous portions. The experience is enriched further with expertly crafted cocktails, like the Basil Hayden and delightful chocolate martinis, setting the tone for an indulgent meal.
Customer reviews highlight the impeccable service that accompanies the culinary offerings. Servers like Richard JH have been recognized for their warm hospitality, ensuring each meal is memorable. The consensus is clear: diners leave the restaurant not just satisfied, but eagerly planning their next visit. One guest remarked that “all the fish tasted fresh and delicious,” a sentiment echoed by many who have experienced the sensational seafood selection.
However, not all experiences have been stellar; some diners note that certain dishes did not meet their expectations in terms of flavor or portion size. This feedback illustrates the importance of continual refinement in maintaining the high standards that Watermark set for itself. Nonetheless, the overwhelming positive reviews suggest that any missteps are far outweighed by the restaurant’s strengths.
In conclusion, Watermark Restaurant is more than just a place to eat; it is a dining experience where the ambiance, service, and delectable menu converge to create something special. For those looking to experience the beautiful vistas of Mayville alongside delightful cuisine, Watermark should undoubtedly be at the top of your list. Don’t just take my word for it—make your reservation today at +1 716-753-2900 and discover what all the buzz is about.
Amazing food Beautiful views Would go back Great service
Gluten and soy-free diner here. What a stupendous meal my dining companion and I had last night. To start I had the Basil Hayden, she tried their chocolate martini. We split some mussels, which were divine. She ordered the Salmon and Scallops, and I tried the Gorgonzola Filet, medium. Both entrees were delicious! We certainly will be back again soon!! Thank you.
This is one of our favorite places to go for seafood in the area. Food was delicious and the service was great! There's a great view of the lake inside or outside.
There were six of us, so we made a reservation in advance and were able to get patio seating. The food was top notch. Prime Chicago beef tenderloin was delicious, properly cooked to medium rare. The garlic mashed potatoes were some of the best ever. I started with a gazpacho that was perfect! Everyone at the table raved about the food. To top it off, service was exceptional. One of my best restaurant experiences ever.
Food and service were great! Nice place for a date night or the whole family. Def recommend the grilled lobster and the crab balls. Yummmm
This place was amazing. The seafood here was the best I’ve ever had. All the fish tasted fresh and delicious. Plus portion sizes were amazing! The service staff was more than amazing, and went above and beyond. We brought guests from Canada, and they absolutely loved every single bite.
Waitress Holly was very sweet! The food is over priced for what you get. My entree was a dry baked potato and broiled haddock with shrimp and scallops. No taste. No vegetables/ salad or bread. Left hungry. My husband had fish tacos and they were good but pricey for tacos. Here for vacation and was out last nice dinner out but had to go home and have something more to eat.
Richard JH was amazing. We came over from Erie pa for a camping trip and after a long work week we decide to treat ourselves to a nice dinner outside of camp. Our server was very honest about menu options and even came over at the end of our meal to apologize for not making it back as much as he would have liked and you could tell he was genuine with what he said. The house was packed and we were not bothered at all by this! Highly recommend the blackened tuna and mango salmon were amazing! Great atmosphere, service, food, portions and prices!